Blogs

2026 Year-End Payroll Watch List: Questions Every Small-Business Owner Should Ask

Written by Raeann Hofkin | Nov 18, 2026, 3:15:06 PM

As year-end approaches, taking time to review how the business manages payroll can help identify missing information, resolve outstanding issues, and confirm that reporting requirements are met before W-2s are finalized.

For 2026, new overtime reporting and Roth catch-up requirements deserve particular attention. Health coverage costs and taxable benefits also belong on the watch list.

 

1. Big Beautiful Bill: Identifying Qualified Overtime

Under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, employers must report qualified overtime compensation separately on the 2026 Form W-2 in Box 12, using code TT. For 2025, transition relief allowed employers to report this amount voluntarily, subject to the rules defining qualified overtime.

Qualified overtime reporting depends on the employee’s eligibility and the reason the overtime was paid. Generally, the reportable amount is the premium piece, the extra half-time portion of time-and-a-half pay required under federal overtime law. Payments required by state law, a union agreement, or company policy qualify only to the extent they also meet the federal requirements.

For example, an employee might receive extra pay for working Sunday but work only 32 hours that week. That Sunday premium reflects additional pay for the day worked. Qualified overtime reporting generally covers the extra half-time required by federal law for hours actually worked over 40 in a workweek.

The “no tax on overtime” provision allows eligible employees to claim a deduction on their individual federal income tax returns, subject to applicable limits. Qualified overtime generally remains subject to federal income tax withholding and Social Security and Medicare taxes.

Questions to ponder:

    • Were employees with overtime reviewed?
    • Does the overtime payment need to be reported?
    • Is the payroll system configured and accurately calculating qualified overtime?
    • Have the amounts in Box 12, code TT, been verified?

2. Health Coverage Costs: Does the W-2 Show the Right Amount?

Some employers must report the cost of employer-sponsored health coverage in W-2 Box 12, using code DD. Generally, this includes both the employer and employee portions of reportable coverage. The amount is informational only.

Under existing IRS relief, reporting is generally optional for employers required to file fewer than 250 W-2s for the preceding calendar year. Employers should confirm whether the reporting requirement or relief applies to their business.

Where reporting applies, the figures should reflect coverage provided during the year, including enrollment changes and changes in coverage cost. The full reportable amount generally combines the employer’s share of coverage costs with the employee’s share.

Questions to ask payroll:

    • Is the company required to report health coverage costs, or qualify for reporting relief?
    • Does the amount include both the employer and employee portions of reportable coverage?
    • Were coverage changes, new enrollments, and terminations reflected accurately?
    • Does payroll reporting reconcile with the benefits records?

3. Roth Catch-Up Contributions: Were the Right Employees Identified?

Beginning in 2026, a SECURE 2.0 requirement affects certain employees making age-based catch-up contributions to applicable employer retirement plans. Employees whose 2025 Social Security wages from the employer sponsoring the plan exceeded $150,000 generally must make their catch-up contributions as Roth, or after-tax, contributions. Catch-up eligibility generally begins at age 50.

The Roth requirement applies specifically to the catch-up portion of an affected employee’s contributions. For 2026, eligibility is based on the employee’s 2025 Social Security wages from the employer sponsoring the plan.

This new requirement deserves a review this year to confirm that the system is configured correctly and contributions are withheld and reported accurately.

Questions to ponder:

    • Were employees whose 2025 wages exceeded $150,000 contributing the catch-up contributions to the ROTH?
    • Were 2025 Social Security taxable wages (Box 3) used to identify qualifying employees?
    • Were affected catch-up contributions treated as Roth in both payroll and retirement plan records?

Coordinate any corrections with the retirement plan provider so payroll and plan records remain accurate and consistent.

 

Additional Year-End Questions to Ponder:

    • Are there unresolved employee pay or deduction errors?
    • Are all tax ID numbers correct and included in the payroll system?
    • Have all manual checks and voids been entered into the system?
    • Are any payroll tax notices still awaiting action?
    • Have you reviewed the W-2 previews for accuracy before they are finalized?
    • Do you need to approve the quarterly reports before the W2’s are printed?
    • What are the payroll provider’s deadlines for submitting corrections?
    • Who is responsible for following up on outstanding items?

How Chatfield Can Help

Business owners can provide effective payroll oversight by ensuring that someone is asking the right questions and verifying the answers. Chatfield can help assess applicable requirements, review payroll processes and supporting records, investigate discrepancies, and coordinate with payroll, benefits, retirement, and accounting providers. The starting point is understanding your business and identifying where support is needed.

A thorough payroll review today helps ensure accurate year-end reporting.